Unit 4 Discussion: Reasonable Beliefs
77 unread replies.77 replies.
Please read the following sections under Exercise B on page 186 in your textbook, then choose and discuss one (1) of the following events and questions in your initial post. Taking into account the information provided and generally accepted background beliefs, assess the extent to which one of these unusual events is worthy of belief.
- Psychic Surgery, located on page 187
Based on what you have learned about reasonable beliefs, are you willing to accept psychic surgery as a genuine phenomenon, given your beliefs about disease, the human body, human nature, and surgery? Refer to your text to support your answer, citing the applicable information.
- Facilitated Communication, located on pages 187-188
Based on what you have learned in your text, is the claim of facilitated communication with autistic children worthy of belief? Provide support for your answer. Be sure to refer to your text, citing the applicable information.
- Loch Ness Monster, located on page 189
Based on what you have learned about reasonable beliefs, what can one reasonably believe about the Loch Ness monster? Be sure to refer to your text, citing the applicable information.
Once you have posted your initial assignment post, be sure to respond to at least two initial posts by your classmates during the week, as required. Your replies should be well-developed, thorough responses in which you consider their answer and discuss your answer to the event, as well.
For more information about discussion grading criteria, visit the Undergraduate Discussion Participation Policies and Rubric page located in ECPI Resources.
Psychic Surgery Thousands of sick people once traveled to the Philippines from all over the world to seek help from the psychic surgeons who were reported to be performing medical miracles, despite the fact that they were all uneducated and untrained in even the most basic medical procedures. Perhaps the most famous of the psychic surgeons was Tony Agpaoa in Manila. Observers claimed they had watched him many times as he plunged his hand inside a patient’s body and plucked out a tumor, kidney stones, or part of diseased liver or lung. When Agpaoa pulled out his hand, witnesses said, the diseased material would be covered with blood, but there would be no sign of an incision in the patient’s skin. Dozens of patients said that Agpaoa had cured them of their diseases, and often these patients’ own doctors had told them their diseases were incurable or inoperable. Are you willing to accept psychic surgery as a genuine phenomenon, given your beliefs about disease, the human body, human nature, and surgery?
How to solve
Unit 4 Discussion: Reasonable Beliefs, health and medicine homework help Nursing Assignment Help
Introduction:
Based on the provided information and generally accepted background beliefs, we will now assess the extent to which psychic surgery is worthy of belief. Psychic surgery has been practiced by uneducated and untrained individuals in the Philippines, with claims of performing medical miracles. One of the most famous psychic surgeons, Tony Agpaoa, was reported to have successfully removed tumors, kidney stones, and diseased organs from patients without leaving any visible incisions.
Answer:
Given my beliefs about disease, the human body, human nature, and surgery, I am not willing to accept psychic surgery as a genuine phenomenon. Psychic surgery goes against the established principles and practices of modern medicine, which is based on scientific evidence, rigorous training, and standardized procedures.
Firstly, disease is widely understood to be an intricate biological process, often requiring extensive medical knowledge, diagnostic tools, and evidence-based treatments. The claims made by psychic surgeons, performing complex procedures such as removing tumors, kidney stones, or diseased organs, without any visible incisions, contradict our understanding of the intricacies involved in surgical interventions.
Secondly, the human body is a complex organism with well-defined anatomical structures and physiological processes. Psychic surgery’s alleged ability to bypass the skin and underlying tissues to access internal organs without leaving any visible marks defies the fundamental principles of human anatomy. It is improbable that such procedures could be carried out without causing significant harm or damage to the patient.
Thirdly, human nature emphasizes the importance of critical thinking, skepticism, and reliance on empirical evidence. The claims made by psychic surgeons lack scientific validation and are unsupported by peer-reviewed studies or systematic evidence. This undermines the credibility of psychic surgery as a genuine medical phenomenon.
Lastly, surgery is a specialized field that requires years of education, training, and adherence to established guidelines and protocols. Psychic surgeons lacking any formal medical education or training cannot be reasonably expected to possess the necessary skills and knowledge to perform surgical procedures safely and effectively.
In conclusion, based on my beliefs about disease, the human body, human nature, and surgery, I am not willing to accept psychic surgery as a genuine phenomenon. The lack of scientific evidence, inconsistency with established medical practices, and the absence of formal training in the field make it difficult to consider psychic surgery as a credible medical intervention.
