Skinner and other behaviorists believed that reinforcement is more effective than punishment in shaping children’s behavior. Yet there still exists a wide variety of opinions over the best way to raise and discipline children.
Pick a popular parenting media source (e.g., website, book) that emphasizes using token economies and one that emphasizes the use of time-out in responding to children’s behavior. Compare and contrast the benefits of each type. Be sure to describe specific scientific evidence that indicates whether token economies or time-outs are effective parenting practices.
To help ensure the auto-feedback system will function properly, your response must contain a minimum of 100 words and a maximum of 1000 words
Expert Solution Preview
Introduction:
Parenting is one of the most challenging and essential tasks of any person’s life. Every parent faces difficulties in selecting the right approach to discipline and shape their child’s behavior. One of the popular debates in parenting is whether to use token economies or time-out as a method for discipline. This answer will compare and contrast the benefits of token economies and time-out and provide scientific evidence for their effectiveness as parenting practices.
Answer:
Token economies are a behavioral modification technique that uses rewards as an incentive for desirable behavior. The rewards that the child receives are tokens, which can be accumulated and exchanged for desired items or activities. This technique is based on Skinner’s reinforcement theory, which suggests that rewards can increase the frequency of desired behavior in children. Token economies are associated with multiple benefits, such as improving the child’s behavior, increasing their self-esteem, and promoting academic success. According to a study conducted by Kazdin et al. (1986), token economies were effective in reducing disruptive behavior in children with severe conduct problems.
Time-out, on the other hand, is a popular disciplinary technique that involves withdrawing the child from a positive environment in response to undesirable behavior. The child is placed in a quiet, isolated location for a short period to provide them with an opportunity to reflect on their behavior. This technique is based on the principle of punishment, which argues that removing a positive stimulus can decrease the frequency of undesirable behavior. Time-out is linked to several benefits, such as reducing aggressive behavior, increasing compliance, and promoting positive social behavior. In a study conducted by Larzelere and Merenda (1994), time-out was found to be more effective than power assertion techniques in improving children’s behavior.
Despite the benefits associated with both techniques, there are also several limitations and potential risks. For example, token economies may not work for every child, and some children may become too reliant on rewards. Additionally, the tokens may lose their effectiveness over time, and the child’s behavior may return to pre-reinforcement levels. Time-outs, on the other hand, may not be effective for children with underlying behavioral or developmental issues. Some children may also become resistant to time-outs and start to feel rejected or isolated from their parents.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, both token economies and time-out are effective parenting practices for discipline. However, each technique has its unique benefits and limitations that parents should consider when deciding which approach to use. Scientific evidence suggests that token economies are effective in reducing disruptive behavior, while time-outs are more effective than power assertion techniques for improving children’s behavior. Ultimately, parents should choose the approach that best suits their child’s personality, developmental needs, and parenting style.
