- Dr. Baxter and Dr. Larson claim that they have a moral obligation to deliver care. Further, Dr. Baxter asserts that the patient has a moral responsibility to accept care. Offer the best possible argument for this view. Do you find it convincing? Why or why not?
Expert Solution Preview
Introduction:
As medical professionals, the delivery of care is a fundamental responsibility. However, there are differing views on the morality of delivering care and accepting care. In this response, we will examine an argument put forward by Dr. Baxter and Dr. Larson and evaluate its persuasiveness.
Answer:
Dr. Baxter and Dr. Larson hold that delivering care is a moral obligation. They maintain that as medical professionals, they have a duty to use their knowledge and skills to help those in need. This duty is intertwined with their moral responsibility to promote the well-being of all individuals. Furthermore, Dr. Baxter argues that patients have a moral obligation to accept care. This is based on the premise that seeking medical attention when ill or in pain is a necessary step towards improving and safeguarding one’s health.
The best argument for this view is that health is a vital aspect of human life, and access to care is crucial in promoting and maintaining it. Medical professionals have acquired expertise in treating illnesses and promoting health, and they have a responsibility to use this knowledge to benefit society. Individuals also have a responsibility to maintain their health and wellbeing, and accepting care is one way to fulfill this duty.
However, this argument may not be convincing to everyone. Some may argue that individuals have the right to refuse care, even if it is in their best interest. They may also argue that the delivery of care should not be mandatory and that personal autonomy should be respected. Additionally, there are concerns about the cost of care and accessibility to healthcare services, which may prevent individuals from accessing the care they need.
In conclusion, while delivering care and accepting care may be considered moral obligations by some medical professionals, it is a complex issue that will continue to be debated. As future medical professionals, it is crucial to consider these perspectives and reflect on our own beliefs and values regarding the delivery and acceptance of care.
