I’m working on a health & medical discussion question and need the explanation and answer to help me learn.
Resource: Ch. 18 to 19 of The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down.
Respond to the following in a minimum of 175 words:
Was Lia’s life ruined by cross-cultural misunderstandings? Explain your thoughts.
How to solve
MHA 516 University of Phoenix Cross Cultural Misunderstandings Discussion
Introduction:
Cross-cultural misunderstandings can have a profound impact on individuals’ lives, particularly in the realm of healthcare. In the case of Lia, as depicted in “The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down,” these misunderstandings were pervasive and led to significant challenges in both her medical treatment and overall well-being. This essay will explore whether Lia’s life was ruined by these cross-cultural misunderstandings, providing a thoughtful analysis of the factors at play.
Answer:
Lia’s life was undeniably affected and disrupted by cross-cultural misunderstandings. One of the main contributors to this was the clash between the Hmong cultural beliefs and the Western medical system. The Lee family firmly adhered to their Hmong traditions and considered illness to be a spiritual matter. On the other hand, the medical professionals involved viewed Lia’s condition through a purely scientific lens, leading to conflicting understandings and a constant struggle to bridge the cultural gap.
Miscommunication further complicated matters, exacerbating the mistrust between the Lee family and the medical staff. Linguistic barriers hindered effective communication, resulting in a lack of accurate information exchange and misunderstandings about Lia’s condition and treatment plan. As a result, essential medical instructions were not always followed, leading to worsening symptoms and inconsistent care.
Furthermore, the cultural insensitivity displayed by some healthcare providers amplified the misunderstandings. Insensitive comments, such as labeling the Hmong’s traditional spiritual practices as mere superstition, not only disregarded their cultural beliefs but also undermined their trust in Western medicine. This disregard for Hmong culture and alternative healing practices hindered the development of a collaborative and inclusive healthcare approach, further complicating Lia’s medical journey.
The consequences of these cross-cultural misunderstandings were far-reaching. Lia experienced recurrent seizures, each time diminishing her physical and cognitive capabilities. Her family’s deep-seated mistrust of the healthcare system led to limited access to medical care and delayed response during emergencies. Moreover, the immense stress imposed by the ongoing conflicts between cultural values hindered Lia’s overall well-being.
In conclusion, cross-cultural misunderstandings played a significant role in disrupting Lia’s life. The clash between Hmong traditions and Western medicine, combined with miscommunication and cultural insensitivity, led to detrimental consequences for her health and well-being. The situation highlights the critical importance of understanding and respecting cultural diversity in healthcare settings, as cross-cultural misunderstandings can have profound and potentially ruinous effects on individuals’ lives.
