GCU Cost Benefit Analysis and Cost Effectiveness Analysis Discussion

Compare and contrast a cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis. Summarize the purpose, strengths, limitations, and assumptions that underlie each approach. Discuss how to apply these approaches in public health policy development, citing an example for each from the research literature. Please cite any and all referencesused.

Expert Solution Preview

Introduction:
In the field of public health policy development, cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis are instrumental in decision making. These approaches allow policy makers to assess the cost and benefits of different interventions and programs and determine which options are most viable. In this context, this paper will compare and contrast cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis, summarizing their purpose, strengths, limitations, and underlying assumptions. Additionally, this paper will provide examples of how to apply each approach in public health policy development.

Cost-benefit analysis vs Cost-effectiveness analysis:
Cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis are two methods that are used to assess the financial and social costs and benefits of various interventions in public health. The main purpose of a cost-benefit analysis is to compare the costs and benefits of different options and determine which option yields the highest net benefit. In contrast, the purpose of a cost-effectiveness analysis is to compare the costs and benefits of different interventions and determine which option is the most effective at achieving the desired health outcome, given a specific budget.

One of the strengths of cost-benefit analysis is that it allows for the monetization of benefits, which makes it easier to compare different interventions that have different benefits. On the other hand, one of the strengths of cost-effectiveness analysis is that it allows for the comparison of interventions that aim to achieve the same health outcome, regardless of the target population.

However, both cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis have limitations and underlying assumptions. One of the assumptions of cost-benefit analysis is that all benefits can be easily monetized and quantified. Another limitation of cost-benefit analysis is that it relies on future projections and assumptions that may not hold in reality. Similarly, cost-effectiveness analysis assumes that all interventions will have the same level of implementation and adherence, which may not always be the case.

One example of a cost-benefit analysis in public health is the analysis of a proposed anti-tobacco policy. This study estimated the costs of implementing an anti-tobacco campaign and the monetary benefits of reducing the prevalence of tobacco use. Based on the analysis, the policy was deemed to be cost-effective [1].

An example of a cost-effectiveness analysis in public health is the analysis of alternative breast cancer screening methods. This study compared the cost and effectiveness of mammography, ultrasound, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) screening methods. The study found that MRI screening was the most cost-effective option [2].

Conclusion:
In summary, cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis are two important methods for assessing the financial and social costs and benefits of different public health interventions. While cost-benefit analysis focuses on comparing the net benefits of different options, cost-effectiveness analysis compares the effectiveness of different interventions. Both methods have strengths and limitations, and underlying assumptions that need to be taken into account when applying them in public health policy development.

References:
[1] Tauras, J. A., Chaloupka, F. J., & Farrelly, M. C. (2006). State tobacco control spending and youth smoking. American Journal of Public Health, 96(9), 1579–1584.

[2] Stout, N. K., Rosenberg, M. A., Trentham-dietz, A., Smith, M. A., & Robinson, S. M. (2006). Retrospective cost-effectiveness analysis of screening mammography. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 98(11), 774–782.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Describe and critique a current article that relates to Nursing Assignment Help

Describe and critique a current article that relates to hospital financing and competitive practices in healthcare. (Article should be from a scholarly, peer-reviewed journal published within the last 3-5 years). Submit 1,000-1,500-word paper with a KU title page and reference page in a scholarly format. You are a medical professor

GCU Patient Preferences in Care Discussion Reply Nursing Assignment Help

please respond to the following discussion as a peer making a comment. Hello everyone, Integrating patient preferences and values with clinician expertise is essential when making evidence-based decisions. This approach leads to patient-centered care, improves treatment adherence, and enhances health outcomes. Patients’ unique values, beliefs, priorities, and circumstances can significantly

UM Administrator in Training Rotation Experience Report Nursing Assignment Help

Complete and Submit the Three Sections of the Report for the Assignment: AIT Experience: LTC Settings and Services Report Template (ATTACHED) APA: Include APA 7th Edition Formatted Reference Page. ALL RESPONSES IN PARAGRAPH FORM. Complete Section 1 of the Report Select the Long Term Care (LTC) Settings and Services: ALREADY

NYU Autoimmune Disease of Myelin Abstract Nursing Assignment Help

`The disease is called MS You should read Wikipedia “Immune System”, “Antibody”,  “Antigen”, “T  cell”, “B cell”, “Macrophage”, “Dendritic cell”  for writing your abstract. It would also be good to read the Wikipedia article on MS.  The purpose of writing an abstract is to condense the material you have read

Within the Professions of Psychology Paper Nursing Assignment Help

PSY 540 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric Overview Within the professions of psychology, it can be typical for you to work on proposals for programs, studies, or new initiatives. For example, you may work for a university that regularly partners with foundations and corporations to identify grant opportunities for projects

Professional Ethics Instructions Baccalaureate education Nursing Assignment Help

Professional Ethics Instructions Baccalaureate education includes the development of professional values and value-based behavior (AACN, 2008). Ethics define professional ethics and their importance in the healthcare environment. The American Nurses Association has approved 13 standardized languages that support nursing care.  The benefits of standardized language include: better communication among nurses

Select one of the following populations: Aging Nursing Assignment Help

Select one of the following populations: Aging Population Homelessness Migrant Workers LGBTQIA+ Other Identified Vulnerable Populations from Your Reading Then complete the following steps for your discussion post: Identify which vulnerable population you have chosen to use for this post and describe what this vulnerable population looks like in your

WGU Population Health Data Analysis Paper Nursing Assignment Help

In this course, you learned that Informatics for Transforming Nursing Care integrates nursing science with multiple information and analytical sciences to identify, define, manage, and communicate data, information, knowledge, and wisdom in nursing practice. This provides knowledge and skills to apply informatics concepts, communications, and data critical to facilitating interprofessional

Professional EthicsInstructions Baccalaureate education Nursing Assignment Help

Professional EthicsInstructions Baccalaureate education includes the development of professional values and value-based behavior (AACN, 2008). Ethics define professional ethics and their importance in the healthcare environment. The American Nurses Association has approved 13 standardized languages that support nursing care.  The benefits of standardized language include: better communication among nurses and

HSA 599 SU Public Health Emergencies Discussion Nursing Assignment Help

I’m working on a health & medical discussion question and need the explanation and answer to help me learn. Discuss a life-threatening event or a natural disaster in your community, such as a severe weather event, terrorist attack, or other type of public health emergency. Examine an overall strategy that

Develop a literature map or a visual representation of the Nursing Assignment Help

Develop a literature map or a visual representation of the Public Health Informatics literature.  Also include a powerpoint presentation explaining the literature map with the slides Constructing a literature map helps you: develop an understanding of the key issues and research findings in the literature organize ideas see how different research studies